Joan Semmel – Intimacy/Autonomy (1974)

If to empathize means to put yourself in someone else’s place, then Joan Semmel’s self-portraits offer us an exercise in empathy. Four decades before selfies became a thing, this American artist was resorting to photography to document her body and sexuality, an approach that offered her a unique vantage point, further explored through painting. One element to keep in mind is that Semmel was, and still is, a staunch feminist, who has always contested the way women are portrayed in pornography, media and the arts – as sexual objects, existing only for the viewers’ gratification.

Not surprisingly, many art critics and fans have viewed Semmel’s art through these feminist optics, while perhaps overlooking its artistry, skillful composition and ingenious use of color. Though her early career was defined by abstract expressionism, by 1974 her art had reached a turning point: she embraced figuration, using her own body to capture “the feeling of self, and the experience of oneself” and offer us, for a change, the opportunity to explore nudity from a woman’s point of view. “My return to the figure in 1970, from an Abstract Expressionist background, was prompted by a need to work from a more personal viewpoint…to express personal and social concerns has led me to the most literal possible interpretation of female self-determination, a first person definition of self”, is how the artist explained her departure from her earlier works.

Joan Semmel - Intimacy-Autonomy
Joan Semmel – Intimacy-Autonomy (1974), oil on canvas

Painted in a photorealistic style, Intimacy – Autonomy is one of Semmel’s best known works, showing the artist with her partner, lying naked in bed. Their foreshortened bodies can only be seen from the neck down, since the perspective is set at the top of the bed. It was actually Semmel’s camera that originally recorded this moment, which later became the entry point for the viewer’s presence. Instead of turning us into voyeurs, we are as much a part of the painting as the couple is. It’s not so much an identification with either one of the partners, but the chance to inhabit the space between them, their intimacy and the opportunity to live a moment as seen from either one’s perspective. It’s as if we’re physically there, our gaze following their stretched limbs down the middle of the bed.

And as they’re lying there, relaxed and vulnerable in their post-sex nudity, the two lovers’ intimacy isn’t defined by desire –since it’s already been consumed – but by their bodies and the physical boundaries which they impose. Notice how in spite of being so close to one another, the partners do not touch or overlap. It’s an intimacy shared while maintaining one’s independence.

Given her background in abstract expressionism, the American artist had always placed a great emphasis on color. But as opposed to her other 1970s erotic artworks, defined by warmer, vivid and complementary hues, here the bodies appear almost statuesque – especially her own, which looks like it’s made of stone. The grays and blues turn this moment into a slightly chilly scene, perhaps a reference to the lovers cooling down after sex. Whatever the intention of the artist was, the foreshortening and the cool colors make this couple look larger than life, a landscape of bodies on a pale apricot bed sheet, with the deep blue of the wall above the horizon.

8 Comments Add yours

  1. David says:

    To me the foreshortening looks a little extreme, stretched out too much. The feet seem to be a lot smaller than I would expect. I wonder if this is from using a wide angle lens and if there would have been less foreshortening if not done from a photograph. Also the lower right leg on the man seems disjointed to me. It looks as though it has been cut off at the knee and placed perpendicular to the upper leg but to far back from the end of the upper leg. All in all though I do like the painting and I think that what I call extreme foreshortening adds to its interest.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Gabriela says:

      It looks like some selfies are in order to really test this out! I assume she used a wide angle lens. But even if it was all artistic license, I love that larger-than-life effect that she achieves by painting the feet much smaller than the rest of their bodies.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. M.B. Henry says:

    For me this also captures the vulnerability that comes with being intimate, showed by the distance between them yet how close their hands are – it seems like they maybe want to hold hands but can’t quite get there. To me it brings to life that intense feeling of vulnerability that is almost scary as you completely trust another with your feelings. A very neat piece and I always applaud women being portrayed as something other than objects!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Gabriela says:

      That’s a wonderful interpretation, M. B! It didn’t even cross my mind. I guess that knowing how personal this was to Semmel, I didn’t want to assume too much about what she was trying to convey. But you’re very much right, the lovers could be at the beginning of a relationship when they’re still afraid to let go of their independence and trust each other completely.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Maverick ~ says:

    The colors stood out to me, as you aptly explained there’s a certain coldness to it. I think it’s interesting that she’s doing selfies as she ages.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Gabriela says:

      I definitely want to feature one of Semmel’s aging selfies too. When it comes to Intimacy/Autonomy I think it’s equally important to see male nudity from a woman’s perspective. We almost never get this chance.

      Liked by 2 people

  4. KD says:

    “…offer us, for a change, the opportunity to explore nudity from a woman’s point of view.” So true. So much of classical art depicts the female form but it’s usually from another (male) perspective. There is such ownership present here. I like the selection of colours used and then I read your suggestion for the use of those colours and it made perfect sense. Very thought-provoking piece.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Gabriela says:

      Thank you, KD! I’m so glad you enjoyed this painting. It’s truly thought-provoking indeed.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s